Saturday, 10 March 2012

Some things are just non-negotiable for now.


photo by  Roberto Stuckert Filho, taken from the UOL website.


Dilma Rousseff, Brazil’s current President, is going to the United States next month on a State visit. And just for a change, the Brazil-US relations are expected to remain difficult in 2012. During her trip, which is supposedly going to be one of the most important of her mandate, several issues are to be in the minute. Obama is supposed to persuade her to follow the US Foreign Policy. On his side, it is important to make sure Brazil is supportive of more sanctions for both Syria and Iran. However, Dilma will try to change the focus of the conversation to less important issues to the international community, such as the process to earn an America Student VISA in Brazil. 

The VISA earning process is not supposed cause any major change in the bilateral relations. It is more of a popular theme in Brazil and part of her electoral promises on education. Regarding the High Politics to be discussed in this meeting, though, I am positive that Brazil will not give in to the US FP, and the US will not recognise (in fact) Brazil's international importance. 

Brazil is not even asking for money this time. Just having a little bit of support from the US would be ok to make the relation between both countries a lot better. Obama was the first American president to visit Brazil in almost a decade. And that shows how important Brazil really is for the American foreign agenda. During his visit, back in 2011, he could have had a lot of important subjects to discuss and investments to propose. But instead of calling the attention for pushing on trade negotiations, for example, he made a relevant announcement authorising the airstrikes in Libya. And it is just very important to remember Brazil was against this kind of action the whole time! 

Brazil has its own point of view regarding international sanctions and interference. Firstly, regarding Iran’s nuclear plan, Brazil itself has one of most modern nuclear programs on Earth. Maybe for this reason it tends not to deny Iran the right to develop its own nuclear program. That is, as long as the nuclear power is for civil means only and there is no disrespect to international law. But the truth is that Ahmadinejad has acquired to himself a lot of international unfriendliness. And unlike the rest of the world, Brazil is one of the few who think it is still possible to favour the diplomacy with Iran… 

And secondly, regarding Syria, Brazil keeps the same principle that guided its positions in the UNSC all through 2011. During a national uprising, it is up for the people of that country to reach an agreement - locally. While the international community has already made its mind and supports the opposition, Brazilian diplomats hold up to the idea that Syrians should reach an agreement alone - under the eyes of the international community. And even though some are comparing Brazil to Russia and China, it is far from sharing the same interests with the two other countries. While China is interested in Syrian oil and Russia is interested in selling weapons to Assad’s regime, Brazil could not be seeking for more than just international support and diplomatic recognition (which sounds much nobler). 

No matter what Obama says in April, I don’t think Dilma is changing the course of her national foreign policy anytime soon. Even though the Syrian and Iranian regimes are considered to be oppressive and undemocratic to their peoples, she will remain to the juridical principle that “everyone is innocent until proven guilty”. And if Americans want to promote an intervention in Iran with the Brazilian support, it should it least present strong evidence that a bomb is being developed first. After all, everybody still remembers George W. Bush guaranteeing on TV that Iraq had nuclear weapons back in 2001. Nowadays, everyone knows the truth. 

Just concluding, the same applies to Syria. In this case, there is also a new concept created by the Brazilian diplomatic agency called “Responsibility while protecting”. Basically it complements the idea of “responsibility to protect” and makes it a little more complex. If someone wants to promote stronger sanctions on Syria, or help bring of Assad’s regime to an end, there should be first a full recovery plan for that country. After all, again, everyone remembers the US, France and the UK lobbying for stronger sanctions on Libya last year. In the end, the country was freed from its dictator, but kept in chaos with the constant risk of a new civil war and internal divisions.

1 comment:

  1. Ola Joao Pedro,

    Parabéns, muito bom artigo.

    Mas é importante lembrar que o presidente George Bush sim veio ao Brasil em 2007, entāo o Obama nāo era o primeiro presidente americano em quase uma década a visitar o Brasil. Sempre é bom pesquisar e reconfirmar as informações antes de publicá-las. Só é uma dica.

    Muito bom trabalho.

    Abs

    ReplyDelete