Monday, 12 December 2011

Does England deserve to be part of the EU?



Jumping to the conclusion, I would say it currently does not. Firstly, everybody needs to understand that the European Union took years to be developed. It is the result of years of conversations, negotiations and donations. Idealism has been the main ideological trend there. The whole idea that uniting the institutions and combining policies would create a safer place and promote development brought Europe to what is it today. The UK, however, seems to be in a different page.

Just during the last week, the 27 members of the EU gathered in Brussels to make one step further towards regional integration. However, pledging to be defending UK’s national interests, David Cameron vetoed alone the changes in previous treaties and created a really bad atmosphere in the region. It was the only country to veto the decision (out of 27), including the other countries out of the eurozone.

The idea was that everyone would confirm the needs for further communitarian fiscal regulation and also announce more taxation in the European financial market. This would create a new tool to prevent future crises, and would also help stanch the crisis in Greece, for instance. But there comes Mr Cameron, in Belgium, defending the selfish blows from Downing St. European regulation in UK’s financial system would hurt its sovereignty and take away its source of money. According to Cameron, Britain’s national interest in the organization could be summarized in the "the single market trade, investments, jobs, (and) growth". Britain would not be willing to help and give away at the moment, I suppose.

I believe things are not clear enough for the British. Europe is about giving away - giving away sovereignty in order to avoid asymmetries. It is about mixing - mixing nations and cultures in order to create new, european and globalized ones. It is about trying - trying new things that have never been tried before. And at last (but not least), it is about making capitalism more efficient. Europe is the only place in the world where people, goods and services can move freely, following the law of the market. So I am guessing some British did not get the whole thing right.

Many analysts are saying this will be the end of Britain in the EU. If that happens, this would probably mean the change of centuries of British national strategy. With the Pound Sterling being one of the least competitive currencies in the world, life is surely going to be much harder for the British industries and businesses. The UK would lose its main commercial partner (the EU as a whole) and it would be forced to deepen its dependence on very few others (the USA and China).  

The thing is that the UK needs to show at least a sign of good faith in order to keep itself as part of the group. It needs to do more than just announcing its interest in the region and showing up at EU meetings. The UK did not accept to be part of the Schengen Area; it did not accept to be part of the eurozone, it does not follow the same system of measurement, it is more committed to the US than all the other Europeans, it is probably the only country in the region that has not implemented a competitive public education system... And these are just some of the very many differences the UK keeps with the rest of Europe. (The British people vote for Nigel Farage!)

Allowing “two Europes” in the same group is not the answer. The decisions in the organization should be taken by all of its members, not just part of them. I would say let the UK decide whether it wants to be part of the club or not; but someone has make it decide which side to take. Allowing one country alone to enjoy just part of the benefits of being a member is obviously only going to create more trouble in the future. 


The region has to hold itself together and make significant changes at once. And Britain has to accept and understand the whole concept of what it means to be an European citizen.  

Thursday, 1 December 2011

The Belo Monte Dam - A Different Approach



Recently, many famous artists around the world have shown interest in the matter of the Belo Monte Dam project. In Brazil, a famous movie’s director even copied the Vote Campaign for the last election year in the US and created the Movimento Gota D’Água (Drop of Water Movement). Internationally, people like Leonardo DiCaprio, Sting, Sigorney Weaver and James Cameron have also offered their help in the campaign and are already gathering support all around the world.

Let me just say am also not supportive of the Dam. Personally, I think there are better ways to invest the money and create energy. However, it really bothers when there are tens of thousands of people around the globe going against Brazil for a bunch of unreal facts told by Hollywood stars.

The environmentalists say the Amazon is untouchable; I say we need it for our development. Come on, and everybody knows there are hundreds, if not thousands of ways to take advantage of the environment while preserving it.

However, just for the sake of criticizing the arguments used against the Dam’s construction:
  • Just to start with, the flooded area would correspond to only 0,01% of the “legal Amazon”. It is not really like saying the Amazon will be destroyed, or replaced by the dam. I hate when some people use big number just to make an impression. Of course numbers in the Amazon’s territory are always going to be big. Specially comparing the Amazon with European states...
  • Then, according to Brazilian officials, no indigenous person will be displaced with the construction. The only affected ones will be the actual riparian people According to some, this would even be a good thing, because they would be able to enjoy better public services and social conditions elsewhere. Just saying, considering indigenous people have a whole different set of rights under Brazilian laws, there is a big legal difference in Brazil between riparian and indigenous people).
  • Moreover, the dam’s long period of idleness (8 months, every year) is actually due to environmental concerns. It is not because of lack of possibilities that the dam will not produce energy the same way all year long. According to some Brazilian experts, the dam was planned not to have a bigger reservoir, which would even increase the environmental impacts of the construction.   

Regarding the dam's effects, it is not really its size that concerns me. It is not even the possibly displaced population that worries me. More importantly, it is the Brazilian energetic plan that is on the spot here. And the thing is that many researches have proven that building huge energy generators only helps inflating the existing urban centres. That is, the main cables that are used to transport the electricity always end up going straight to big cities.

So if people think that building a dam in the north/north-east is the right answer for providing the surrounding populations with the proper conditions to develop themselves, I really do not think so. And that was my first point. My second point is that energy is able to drive people out of their original homes. Maybe, along with the dam, there is the possibility that the region’s biggest cities might even become more chaotic. Is it important to point out that inflated urban centres always suffer from lack of urban planning, good public services, poverty, unemployment, and crimes.

Anyway, so what would be the answer for Brazil’s problem? That is, we all have to notice Brazil is very far behind in creating energy than it was supposed to be. In technical terms, Brazil is running a deficitary energy generation program. And due to the necessity to keep growing, Brazil needs new energy sources as soon as possible… Just to have an idea of how big this problem is, some experts said the 2008 crisis’ effects even helped preventing an energetic shut down in the country.

So what is the answer for Brazil’s national problem?
  • For the short term, I believe we should go back to supporting Ethanol. We should even expand Petrobras’s plans to build more total-flex thermoelectric plants around the country.  For those who do not know, Brazil’s Petrobras recently invented greener thermoelectric plants, also operated with ethanol.
  • And for the long term, I truly believe that answer is in the energy produced by the sun. That includes both winds and radiation. And according to the Global Wind Outlook, the perspectives especially for the wind’s energy’s potential are fantastic. In Brazil there is a governmental program that is responsible for funding projects related to the use of alternative sources of energy – PROINFA. For the close future, I really hope it grows.

One affirmation by Ricardo Rüther, a Brazilian electrical expert from University of Santa Catarina (UFSC) is quite intriguing, if you think about it. According to him, “the less exposed Brazilian City to solar radiation (Florianópolis), receives at least 40% more solar energy the anywhere in Germany”. And even though producing solar panels in Brazil should be cheap (for its vast mines of silicon), it is Germany, the US and Japan who currently correspond to 89% of global capacity of installed technology.

And regarding wind power, Brazil is also quite promising in that field. Apart from counting with a big coast line, Brazil is also impacted by five different air masses.     

Dangers to ideal solutions:

In a few years, Brazil is expected to start exploring one of the world’s top 5 biggest oil reserves. It still depends on getting the right technology, but it is clear to me that all the oil companies are cooperating for this cause in the country. Opposing what most people might think, the main cause for recent investments in the Brazil is not the World Cup (2014) or the Olympic Games (2016), but the pre-salt oil exploration (estimated for 2018).

Anyway, I would not be surprised if the future thermoelectric plants were not total flex. And I would not be surprised either if the production (and improvement) of ethanol was left aside. After all, the gas and the oil would be right there, as cheap as it could be… So why doing what is more complex? 


If you want to help the Belo Monte cause, please watch this film and support a Brazilian serious inniciative: (Even though I do not agree on the issue with the indigenous people, I believe they actually deserve to be heard).