Sunday, 13 January 2013

The unbelievable has happened to Venezuela



Following my last post on Venezuela, I think that we can now say that the unbelievable happened in that country. How foreseeable was it, though? Just one day before January 10th, the government announced that Chavez would not be able to make it on time. They decided that the inauguration should be postponed (indefinitely), and that Maduro should be the one in charge until then. Up until this part, taking into account Maduro’s previous declarations on TV, they did exactly as they said.

And on the other side, the opposition tried to go to the courts and change this situation. They defended that inauguration should be on the 10th, that a medical junta should be established, and that the Speaker of the National Assembly should be in charge of the country while no new president was elected. In Venezuela, though, Chavez is mostly considered a hero; and this move certainly was seen by many as if they were just trying to take advantage of Chavez’s current debility. By any means, the Venezuelan Supreme Court ended up recognizing the legality of what the government did. But, have they ever seen any unconstitutionality in Chavez, anyway?

But of course the opposition could imagine that, so they also wrote to the Secretary General of the OAS. They expected that the USA would interfere, or at least something would happen. Now, taking into account Insulza’s history, one could also imagine that he would not be willing to take a stand, or start a political war on this. He did what he had to do: basically, he said that if any country was not satisfied with the situation in Venezuela, it should bring the subject to the Permanent Council. He is a member of Chile’s Socialist Party, worked for Allende’s government, graduated in Law, is a former Chilean diplomat and Foreign Minister, and dedicated his life to studying about politics. He knows the value of his words, therefore he watches them very carefully.

But the unbelievable happened. No country took the situation anywhere – not even the USA wanted to comment the Venezuelan Supreme Court’s decision. And neither did Colombia, Mexico, or Chile. Maybe there has not been enough time to do so yet, but even if they did, what consequences would it have, anyway? Argentina would defend Chavez for several reasons, so would Bolivia, Ecuador, Nicaragua, Uruguay, and even Brazil.

In the US, this southern movement is called “the pink tide”, as a derogatory expression referring to the leftist leaders who are currently in power in South America. So as long as Venezuela remains peaceful and supplying oil at a reasonable price, it is like its traditional international opposition has given up on it.

The value of the national constitution was lost, and all that matters now is the popularity of a leader. In the meantime, Nicolás Maduro has the power, with no actual political role, and out of the constitutional mandate. He has not been elected for this role. The democratic processes have been forgotten, and a serious precedent was established. Again, Southern American diplomacy is proving its singularity.


Why bother, anyway?

Saturday, 5 January 2013

How much more unstable could the future of Venezuela be?



Cancer has been taking over south-American politics since the last years of the 00’s. The Paraguayan Fernando Lugo, started this dangerous trend with a lymphoma in 2010, and soon (Venezuela`s) Hugo Chavez came up with a similar problem, (Brazil’s former president) Lula, and finally (Argentina’s) Cristina Kirchner. Actually, even the current Brazilian president Rousseff was diagnosed with cancer in 2009, when she was still working for Lula as his Chief of Staff. If it is to be remembered, by the time she was starting to run for president in 2010, she was still wearing a wig for public appearances.

But speaking of Chavez, as he is the one in focus, he had his own opinion about this unfortunate new South-American political trend. According to him, even the USA could be culpable for the spread of the disease. In a declaration directed to his troops in 2011, he said: “It would not be strange if they had developed the technology to induce cancer and nobody knew about it until now ... I don't know. I'm just reflecting”. "But this is very, very, very strange ... it's a bit difficult to explain this, to reason it, including using the law of probabilities."

The fact is that a little more than a year after Chavez found out about his health condition, there he was, winning again the presidential elections in his country; earning himself the right to stay in power until 2019. Strangely, the 2012 elections were the hardest one for Chavez since he took office in 1999. The centrist Capriles, who had gained national significance as the governor of Miranda state, almost made it in the end, with 44.49% of the votes and the highest ever voter turnout. However, it is possible that the competition this time was too much for the fragile health of Chavez.  Right now it is known that the current and re-elected leader of Venezuela is laid on a bed of a hospital in the city of Habana, Cuba.

According to the information released to the public, he is between life and death, leaving the political future of his country much unknown. If he is unable to take the oath of office and be sworn in, technically he can’t be considered president, and new elections must be called. It must be said, though, that according to the constitution of that country, Chavez wouldn't necessarily have to be in Venezuela for his inauguration. As per art 231 of the Venezuelan Constitution, he could simply do it to the Supreme Court - from Cuba.

The problem is that he is too weak for anything. And as he is not responding properly to the treatments, he is clearly unable to be inaugurated. But all would be better if this judgement was this quick and easy. As per art 233 of the Constitution, the Supreme Court would need to designate (with the National Assembly`s approval) a special medical commission to deeply evaluate Chavez’s conditions. And given the support the president has in congress, it seems clear that nothing happen before due date.

Before December 2012, it would be hard for anyone to think of a successor for Chavez in Venezuela. After the announcement given by Chavez himself on the State sponsored channel (TeleSur), “if anything happened to him”, the person he would want to carry on his political project is his current vice-president Nicolás Maduro - a person who was a bus driver in his early life, and entered politics as an unofficial unionist back in 80’s. Out of curiosity, their close relationship dates back to 1994, when Maduro’s wife headed Chavez’s defense in the courts, releasing him from prison after his coup attempt in 1992. His wife, by the way, apart from being an ex-deputy of Venezuela, currently keeps the office of Attorney-General in that country. Maduro has been a congressman a few times, was a member of the Constituent Assembly in 1999, elected Speaker of the National Assembly in 2005, and then nominated Foreign Minister for Chavez in 2006.

NOTE: Considering the radical positions Venezuela has been taking in the international arena and Maduro's position in the government, this may indicate that he was the one behind much of what the world always disliked about Chavez. On the other hand, however, many analysts would say that Chavez has always been too much of a centralizer to follow the opinions of others... And from a honest point of view, this is what makes these days so uncertain for Venezuela. No one knows for sure what to expect from the next president. After all, differently from Lula, who, one could say, was just as strong in Brazil as Chavez is in Venezuela, he hadn’t got the time to prepare a successor for the job – nor the public for a different face.  

If in the end new elections are called, Capriles may come again to the scene. Last year he made a few mistakes in the presidential elections, which he is probably rethinking right now. If he wants to have a better chance in 2013, though, one of the main obstacles this time might be gathering the opposition again and moving a little further central. The parties did it last year, but at the moment they do not even know who to nominate in case of new elections.

If eventually the status quo is to be followed, Maduro will win with a huge advantage in the polls, and the interesting thing is that even the so–called Chavismo may suffer a few changes in the short/medium term. Considering that a new guy will be in office, and that the need for more inner respect will be clear, it is likely that politics in Venezuela turn even a little more authoritarian after Chavez. Just as a start, right now he is trying to frame up the opposition, warning the people about a mysterious coup attempt on TV. Also, in many occasions he is showing little respect for the constitution, e.g. by defending that the inauguration is a mere formality.

By any means, the commander’s premature absence from government can be a true window of opportunity for Venezuela’s new political theatre. Without Chavez, even though Maduro now counts with big enough support from his party and could be considered an already well-established politician in the country, the easy forecast is that he will not be nearly as strong and invincible as his predecessor. No one will be as charismatic as Chavez; no one to come will have the same attachments to the armed forces. By the way, one of the good things is that no one will have the same patience to star the endless appearances on national TV.

At the end, Venezuela can be living right now the beginning of a new era for its politics.

Saturday, 29 September 2012

Back to writing... SPAIN IS IN FOCUS!


So I finally found a reason to start writing on my blog again. The point now is not just to get on the frame the most notorious protests in the world; it is about telling the world how important they are – and what difference they can really make.

I was a pessimist about the Arab Spring right from the beginning. I could see there was no truth in most of those popular movements. I do not mean I supported the dictators who were in charge, but in fact I just could not see a real change coming. Now, some time after the three biggest cases (Tunisia, Libya and Egypt), I guess I can say I was right. 

Regarding the Anonymous movement ("Occupy Wall Street", and so on), I must say I have always been a pessimist as well. How can so many people just go camping in front of the main buildings of the capitalist world, and not have one single (real) proposal to make? They called for change, and that was it. Not one single, clear, straight proposal. Instead, there was just the vague demand for CHANGE.

But as the old saying teaches us: if you don’t have anything good to say, don’t say anything at all!

Basically, what I am saying is: I support a harder control by the governments onto the financial market, I like the idea of taxing the rich individuals more, I support the creation of intelligent social programs – there are a zillion changes I support. But how could that (or any) movement actually make a difference, if they did not even know what change they were expecting to be made?

In addition, there is one other crisis that everybody comments everyday. It is the fiscal crisis in Europe, and the riots against the austerity programs that were developed by the governments. Differently from the last two examples, though, I must say that there are so many political factors combined with economic ones, that it makes it almost impossible for any analyst to make a rational prediction of what is going to happen. After all, should Greece leave the eurozone? Should Spain? Would the world take it as a rational move from the political leaders? Or would people take it as a proof of absolute failure and total decontrol in one of the most important economic centres of the world? 

Regarding Greece, it is quite obvious for me that the Greeks will never decide on their own to leave the euro. Greece could not sustain itself without the financial help from Germany (and France, until little time ago, at least). It is true that investments from that country could continue regardless of the currency. It would only take a nice formal exchange market, and investments could start flowing again. However, in my opinion, if they are experiencing instability now, imagine bringing their old currency back overnight. There would be huge operational costs, and how could they take all the contracts that were made in euros and just change them into drachmas? And there would come the political costs… It is just too hard! 

A transformation like that could provoke a massive capital flight, which could have unthinkable trickle-down effects in the short term. How could you tell people that they got used to earning a certain wage, but from some point they would start making half that wage?  Anyway, everybody wants somebody to make an effort, but nobody wants to make it itself. There are still too many questions without  answers in Europe.



Now, there is a movement in which I truly believe. They anticipated (and influenced) the so called “Anonymous” movement around the world, but kept their individuality in a very singular way. I am talking about the Indignados (Spanish term for indignant), and their constant call for a new institutional reform in Spain. They started back in 2011, but came back with a lot more strength in 2012.



The Spanish government is facing a lot of pressure from the people on the streets, and the riots are already out of control. The police have arrested the first person to form the movement (a many others, indeed), but I am not sure whether it is going to be enough to stop them. Anyway, it seems to me that they are a quite interesting popular movement to follow.


And more importantly, it is not just an organized movement of the people against the governmental austerity plans. The "Indigdados" are aiming to make a change locally, but they could have a great impact in the whole of the European scenario. It is one popular movement in a country whose people(s) do not always feel attached to the central government and to a unified national identity. So what I mean by that is that a Spanish austerity plan can bring about much more than just social discomfort and bad economic indicators.


Don't miss the next post!

Friday, 6 April 2012

"C'est dommage"... Populism and Socialism leading the French elections.

   
According to some significant newspapers, no French presidential elections have been as poor in alternatives as the current one...

Fighting out of the right corner, there is Nicolas Sarkozy, who is believed to be one of the less popular French President in recent history. He is currently struggling to gets people's support on the streets, as many are upset with his presidency. However, he is certainly very energetic, and has managed to lead France through one of the most significant economic crisis in history.    

And fighting out of the left corner, there is the contender of this year, François Hollande. He is more educated than his counterpart. He has attended HEC-Paris, Science-Po and the (most) traditional ENA. Actually, that is about all most people know about him. He is promising to raise taxes on the super-rich and to create over 200,000 state-funded jobs in France(60,000 spots for teacher, 150,000 for first-time workers). He is in favour of gay marriage, says he hates the rich and that his main enemy in the elections is finance. 


Initial considerations:


Regarding Sarkozy first: he was previously elected in 2007, representing the centre-right-leaned party UMP. Back then, he promised to get his fellow citizens back at work and to end the welfare state culture in his country. During the course of his mandate, he failed to deliver some of his promises and starred a handful of national scandals.  Just a little after winning the elections, he got divorced, married to a supermodel/singer; and now he often shows up the front page of celebrity magazines like (the international) Vanity Fair and (the French) Gala... Some of his biggest scandals were due to his son’s nomination for an important political position in Paris, the deployment soldiers to Ivory Coast and Afghanistan, the sending of aircrafts to Libya, and for defending a stronger role of the State in the economy (which is not as right-leaned as he should be).

Now, Regarding messr Hollande: despite his successful academic background, in the past few years he was blamed by his party for poor elections performances in the country. In the last presidential elections (2007), he ended up losing the party's nomination for Segolène Royal, the mother of his four children. As everybody knows, she  lost to Sarkozy. Actually, many people believe Messr Hollande only got his shot this year because Dominique Strauss Kahn, who belonged to his party,  was involved in a very controversial sex scandal in New York City.

Anyway, 


The 2012 French Presidential elections will be a huge event for many people throughout the world. EU experts are beginning to draw new lines for some European institutions, businessmen are worried about their earnings (and how they will be affected by the higher taxes), and journalists do not really know how to position themselves. But one thing is for sure: whoever wins there in May is very likely to cause an enormous impact in the future of European integration and global economy.

What can the French people and the world expect from Sarkozy if he wins? 


It’s difficult to say it for sure. I guess the proper answer for this question would be “more of the same”. It is true that he has become more socialist then people would like him to be. He hasn't stood up for his root beliefs in the past years, and changes his speech very often.  I would say he goes with the flow, and that for now, he will probably just continue to surf the right-leaned wave that hit France a few weeks ago in Toulouse.

I do not think there would be a big change in the economic field. Maybe Sarkozy is going to be more protectionist in the short term, as he is attepting to raise taxes and tariffs. But in his last speeches, he has choosen to adopt a pretty curious populist tone for an European politician. In the political European arena, he is expected to continue talks with Germany and to fight for the euro. Maybe his biggest “contribution” for Europe would be his current demand for policy reform in the Schengen Passport-Free Area. 

The current (almost absolute) lack of border control is clearly not working out for France. Actually, believe it or not, amid this entire economic crisis in Europe, Sarkozy has almost stopped talking about this subject. His strategy is to focus on the National Security issue, which is calling a lot more attention now in France. Muslims there are the ones who should be (most) worried in case "Sarko" wins...

Truth is that the French are very proud of themselves. They are proud of their culture above anything else in the world. The French may be struggling as much as they are to reduce their debt and deficit, for example, but if some Arab immigrants, for any reason, appear as “threads” to the French culture, this will be in the heart of all important discussions nationwide.

Messr Hollande, on the other hand, doesn’t look as strong as Sarkozy. Maybe it is his education or his background that makes him look "softer", who knows... He initially focused his efforts on the economy, but this subject just doesn’t have the same effect on people as immigration or extremism has. In his defence, he accuses Sarkozy of not delivering his promises and calls the attention to the cuts on security from Sarkozy’s government. 


But what would happen if Messr Hollande finally gets the French presidency this year?

Probably the biggest effect of his victory would be economic. Due to his protectionist preferences and socialist background, European talks would be much more difficult with him in the presidency. Reaching political arrangements with Germany would become too hard. Hence, the Eurozone crisis could probably be extended in some ways. Whether it is for the best of for the worst, if François Hollande wins, geopolitics can change dramatically in Europe. However, his power to deliver would still depend heavily on the legislative elections in June.

Looking ahead, if the Socialist Party gains even more importance then, France could be in a pretty hard situation. Regional political arrangements would be hard to achieve, and business would constantly fell threatened. After all, even though today's France is considered by multinational companies a top country for mantaining some presence, high taxes and tight government control have always been big turn offs for private companies and enterpreneurs.

That is, of course, only if the socialists do well, both in May and in June. 

So what do you say? Who will win the 2012 Presidential Elections in France and what will be the main effects of it?

Saturday, 10 March 2012

Some things are just non-negotiable for now.


photo by  Roberto Stuckert Filho, taken from the UOL website.


Dilma Rousseff, Brazil’s current President, is going to the United States next month on a State visit. And just for a change, the Brazil-US relations are expected to remain difficult in 2012. During her trip, which is supposedly going to be one of the most important of her mandate, several issues are to be in the minute. Obama is supposed to persuade her to follow the US Foreign Policy. On his side, it is important to make sure Brazil is supportive of more sanctions for both Syria and Iran. However, Dilma will try to change the focus of the conversation to less important issues to the international community, such as the process to earn an America Student VISA in Brazil. 

The VISA earning process is not supposed cause any major change in the bilateral relations. It is more of a popular theme in Brazil and part of her electoral promises on education. Regarding the High Politics to be discussed in this meeting, though, I am positive that Brazil will not give in to the US FP, and the US will not recognise (in fact) Brazil's international importance. 

Brazil is not even asking for money this time. Just having a little bit of support from the US would be ok to make the relation between both countries a lot better. Obama was the first American president to visit Brazil in almost a decade. And that shows how important Brazil really is for the American foreign agenda. During his visit, back in 2011, he could have had a lot of important subjects to discuss and investments to propose. But instead of calling the attention for pushing on trade negotiations, for example, he made a relevant announcement authorising the airstrikes in Libya. And it is just very important to remember Brazil was against this kind of action the whole time! 

Brazil has its own point of view regarding international sanctions and interference. Firstly, regarding Iran’s nuclear plan, Brazil itself has one of most modern nuclear programs on Earth. Maybe for this reason it tends not to deny Iran the right to develop its own nuclear program. That is, as long as the nuclear power is for civil means only and there is no disrespect to international law. But the truth is that Ahmadinejad has acquired to himself a lot of international unfriendliness. And unlike the rest of the world, Brazil is one of the few who think it is still possible to favour the diplomacy with Iran… 

And secondly, regarding Syria, Brazil keeps the same principle that guided its positions in the UNSC all through 2011. During a national uprising, it is up for the people of that country to reach an agreement - locally. While the international community has already made its mind and supports the opposition, Brazilian diplomats hold up to the idea that Syrians should reach an agreement alone - under the eyes of the international community. And even though some are comparing Brazil to Russia and China, it is far from sharing the same interests with the two other countries. While China is interested in Syrian oil and Russia is interested in selling weapons to Assad’s regime, Brazil could not be seeking for more than just international support and diplomatic recognition (which sounds much nobler). 

No matter what Obama says in April, I don’t think Dilma is changing the course of her national foreign policy anytime soon. Even though the Syrian and Iranian regimes are considered to be oppressive and undemocratic to their peoples, she will remain to the juridical principle that “everyone is innocent until proven guilty”. And if Americans want to promote an intervention in Iran with the Brazilian support, it should it least present strong evidence that a bomb is being developed first. After all, everybody still remembers George W. Bush guaranteeing on TV that Iraq had nuclear weapons back in 2001. Nowadays, everyone knows the truth. 

Just concluding, the same applies to Syria. In this case, there is also a new concept created by the Brazilian diplomatic agency called “Responsibility while protecting”. Basically it complements the idea of “responsibility to protect” and makes it a little more complex. If someone wants to promote stronger sanctions on Syria, or help bring of Assad’s regime to an end, there should be first a full recovery plan for that country. After all, again, everyone remembers the US, France and the UK lobbying for stronger sanctions on Libya last year. In the end, the country was freed from its dictator, but kept in chaos with the constant risk of a new civil war and internal divisions.

Tuesday, 31 January 2012

The True Face of Foreign Invaders


Not so differently from my other posts, over one year after the beginning of Arab uprisings in 2011, in my opinion we are now entering a new phase for the Arab Spring. More than before, this could be way more critical and might not end up so well for the populations. 

I have already written a little about the new obstacles for rest of the world in the Middle East. Summing up, I said political opposition was not so obvious and powerful in countries like Syria, I said the monarchies had more support from theirs neighbours and from more parts of their peoples to fight the rebels; and I also said that such an abundant existence of oil only makes everything more sensitive and complex. 

But going back to my first subject of interest when I started my Blog in Portuguese, which was the conflict Libya, there are some very interesting facts taking place there again. All the way from March of last year, it has been truthfully identified by most political analysts and reporters that Libya did not enjoy any kind of institution whatsoever. That is, taking down Muammar Gaddafi meant taking down all forms of organisation the country could ever have. The guy actually was the great leader in Libya, and most orders came from him or his people. The national recovery in Libya could be considered, therefore, a complete (re)building of new institutions and values. 

When Muammar was killed, according the NTC itself, most people owned at least one weapon at home. As we all know, this is too much of an unstable ground for any country that just finished a rebellion (or uprising). And just to make things a little bit worse, maybe the NTC would have never actually reached its actual position without the political and military help from the NATO members. However, after the foreign forces left, it was like the country was left to its own luck. 

According to the newest reports from the ground there, people have been living in a complete state of anarchy since the conquest of their freedom. Markets have been sacked, shootings “of happiness” can be heard all day long and there is no police to keep the order. Some people are even protesting for the old days to come back again. Food is much more expensive, the school system in broken and the infrastructure is poor. 

Some countries (like Brazil, Germany and India) saw it happening a long time ago, but they were all criticised when they all chose to be absent in the SC resolution (1973). 

What a great piece of new! NATO gets in, picks a side, makes it win, and then leaves. The local winners struggle to keep up, there is an endless civil war and the country tears itself apart. After so many years, the military industry is the only one to get wealthier and the locals are the only ones to suffer. The UN is once again criticised for not doing its part and nothing get done to help anyone. 

After Rwanda, Angola, Sudan, Liberia, Somalia, etc, etc, etc, here we go to the same old situation over and over again. Is it going to be the time for the Libyan civil war now? After so many bad examples, should we really support a foreign intervention in Syria this year? Just saying, I am not a supporter of dictators. But also, I am just not a supporter of foreign interventions the way they are happening in the present.

Monday, 12 December 2011

Does England deserve to be part of the EU?



Jumping to the conclusion, I would say it currently does not. Firstly, everybody needs to understand that the European Union took years to be developed. It is the result of years of conversations, negotiations and donations. Idealism has been the main ideological trend there. The whole idea that uniting the institutions and combining policies would create a safer place and promote development brought Europe to what is it today. The UK, however, seems to be in a different page.

Just during the last week, the 27 members of the EU gathered in Brussels to make one step further towards regional integration. However, pledging to be defending UK’s national interests, David Cameron vetoed alone the changes in previous treaties and created a really bad atmosphere in the region. It was the only country to veto the decision (out of 27), including the other countries out of the eurozone.

The idea was that everyone would confirm the needs for further communitarian fiscal regulation and also announce more taxation in the European financial market. This would create a new tool to prevent future crises, and would also help stanch the crisis in Greece, for instance. But there comes Mr Cameron, in Belgium, defending the selfish blows from Downing St. European regulation in UK’s financial system would hurt its sovereignty and take away its source of money. According to Cameron, Britain’s national interest in the organization could be summarized in the "the single market trade, investments, jobs, (and) growth". Britain would not be willing to help and give away at the moment, I suppose.

I believe things are not clear enough for the British. Europe is about giving away - giving away sovereignty in order to avoid asymmetries. It is about mixing - mixing nations and cultures in order to create new, european and globalized ones. It is about trying - trying new things that have never been tried before. And at last (but not least), it is about making capitalism more efficient. Europe is the only place in the world where people, goods and services can move freely, following the law of the market. So I am guessing some British did not get the whole thing right.

Many analysts are saying this will be the end of Britain in the EU. If that happens, this would probably mean the change of centuries of British national strategy. With the Pound Sterling being one of the least competitive currencies in the world, life is surely going to be much harder for the British industries and businesses. The UK would lose its main commercial partner (the EU as a whole) and it would be forced to deepen its dependence on very few others (the USA and China).  

The thing is that the UK needs to show at least a sign of good faith in order to keep itself as part of the group. It needs to do more than just announcing its interest in the region and showing up at EU meetings. The UK did not accept to be part of the Schengen Area; it did not accept to be part of the eurozone, it does not follow the same system of measurement, it is more committed to the US than all the other Europeans, it is probably the only country in the region that has not implemented a competitive public education system... And these are just some of the very many differences the UK keeps with the rest of Europe. (The British people vote for Nigel Farage!)

Allowing “two Europes” in the same group is not the answer. The decisions in the organization should be taken by all of its members, not just part of them. I would say let the UK decide whether it wants to be part of the club or not; but someone has make it decide which side to take. Allowing one country alone to enjoy just part of the benefits of being a member is obviously only going to create more trouble in the future. 


The region has to hold itself together and make significant changes at once. And Britain has to accept and understand the whole concept of what it means to be an European citizen.