Monday, 28 November 2011

The conclusions we could draw from 28/11 in Egypt



Having started at 8h00am today, according to Cairo’s official time (GMT+2), the first day of elections post Mubarak ended without many complaints in Egypt. Differently from the past election years, all the problems that could be noticed during the day were mostly related to logistics and lack of preparation for the great amount of voters. And the reason why this is new is because the Egyptians are used to face corruption and oppression in election days.

Even though today’s election does not represent an importance and immediate change for Egypt, it certainly is a big step in terms of re-designing the country’s political structure. The elected parliament shall have the responsibility to draft a new resolution, for the most part. However, it is important to point out that all major decisions will continue to be taken by the junta (currently in charge).  

Let me just make sure I do not intend to sound pessimistic about Egypt’s future. Actually, I personally believe that the Egyptians have shown the world twice in 2011 how people should be involved with government and political issues. At the same time, when I criticized the direction the Revolution was taking, I believe the local people were kind of feeling the same way as I did.

In previous posts (in Portuguese), I defended the idea that the military junta should respect the next (executive) elections no matter what its result is. Moreover, I even defended that it would be best for Egypt if the Armed Forces took part in the next election just as observers and doing the police work. If they decide to run for offices, I am sure there will be other riots and the government will probably lose its chances to gain legitimacy.

For the next following days, it is expected that the Muslim Brotherhood will lead the poll results. And considering its implications for the draft of a new Constitution, the world should definitely keep an eye opened for Egypt from now on. A possible (and probable) direction it might take is the going back to some Islamic traditional interpretations of the law. And despite the fact that the Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood is considered to be a moderate Islamist group, it still offers risks in terms of preserving certain human rights (such as the women’s rights).

It is hard and erroneous to make predictions for the Egyptian future today. Facts are still too recent and full of passion to be rightfully interpreted. What we can say from now is that Egypt should be careful not to make regression in terms of individual liberties. After all, this was one of the causes for the revolution and it was the people as a whole who demonstrated against the old regime. And let me just say there is nothing wrong with the Muslim Brotherhood gaining more space in the political scenario. From my point of view, maybe the perfect combination to fit in and find just the right legitimacy in the Arab world is a parliamentarian mix of moderate Islamists and secular politicians. Nevertheless, some radical anti-Islam people are already starting to say Egypt will follow the Iranian model and become a marginal State...

Concluding, I believe the future of Egypt is yet to be known by the world. The people of that country are the only ones who will decide which path to take, and the only way we can interfere is by warning them about the possible consequences of their decisions. All certainty we can have for the moment is that no one should consider the Lotus Revolution to be over yet.

Friday, 25 November 2011

The Arab Spring is Moving Into a New Phase. Where are the World's Super Powers?



A little more than ten months after the first revolution of the Arab Spring, Ben Ali has already left the government in Tunisia, Mubarak’s regime in Egypt fell, Libya’s Gaddafi was killed, and at the very end, Yemen ‘s Saleh has signed its resignation. These were the most significant results in favour of the people and indicating big local changes for the future.
On the other hand, protests in Morocco did not even last for a week, and the same happened in Algeria. In Oman, the population barely rose, not to mention Saudi Arabia. In Bahrain the government’s repression was so firm that it kept the population from the streets for a while. Even though there were some serious transgressions of Human Rights, there was a complete lack of media coverage - which I will explain on another opportunity. Actually, Bahrain might be the next government to fall in 2012, in case the riots start again.
In Syria, the imbroglio still goes on. The (Sunni) rebels have had enough of the authoritarian (Shiite) government. And as there are constantly barracks being invaded and weapons being stolen they are closer each day to the start of a major civil war. 
Just remember, the exact same thing happened in Libya. Benghazi’s barracks were looted; the people were armed and got prepared for a huge battle. Just a few days later, the city was "on fire”. But Libya is not Syria. Libya is a little country, sparsely populated, isolated in the north of Africa, where the government had the support of only a few other poor and marginal countries.
Syria, otherwise, presents a totally different scenario. Just to begin with, historically they have been both an ally and an enemy of the West. They have expelled the American Ambassador from Damascus in 1957, they are supporters of Hezbollah and have no intentions to fully respect the Human Rights. Oppositely, they helped the U.S. during the Gulf War, they supports the American fight against al-Qaeda and also accept to negotiate with Israel.
Assad, the current Syrian President, has the backing of a very traditional party inside the country; the Ba’ath. Historically Sunni, the Ba'ath recently turned Shia, perhaps losing some of the popularity it enjoyed before. Yet, this fact alone already indicates that an abrupt departure of Assad would leave a power vacuum to be filled, probably by another ruler of the same party. The future is unknown, but we are just speculating on the strength of the other existing political parties in Syria… 
In addition, Syria has quite a reasonable military power, which means that starting an insurgence may present a major barrier to entry. There is a bigger number of important cities and the population is larger than all the other countries that had to deal with big riots during the Arab Spring. A civil war in Syria would turn the whole country into a huge mess and it would create an incredible bloodshed. The proportions of a war like that may have not been seen in the Middle East ever before. 
Nevertheless, smaller countries are concerned and getting ready to fight.
Turkey, the neighbour in the north, has proposed the creation of a buffer zone in the north of Syria to prevent its citizens from requesting political asylum in Ankara…
Saudi Arabia, the main U.S. ally in the region, is trying to prevent further alignment between Syria and Iran. The Saudis are more likely to be willing to fight as the time goes by and the government kills more rebels (just for the sake of them being Sunnis, not for any Human Right or anything in that context). Following a similar mind-set, the same goes for the Qatari Armed Forces, which are also just waiting for an order from the King to invade Syria and protect the Syrian Sunnis.
Iran, which recently has gotten closer to the Syrian regime, may also exert a counter-weight in favour of President Assad. However, the most Ahmadinejad would contribute to a possible war in Syria would be by providing weaponry supplies. I do not believe it would be capable of sending the Iranian army to Syria, for instance. We would have to consider the current internal disagreements between the Presidents and the Ayatollahs in that country. 
Anyway, this could be the next serious Security Council’s preoccupation. 
But at the same, Russia and China just vetoed all possible UN sanctions from being placed upon Syria. After the pro-Western results in Libya, I strongly doubt they will give in to another ambiguous resolution calling for the 'Right to Protect". Just as a reminder, Syria imports weapons from Russia and exports oil to China.
In this Syrian case, no resolution will pass unanimously in the UN. 
Brazil will probably continue to abstain, accompanied by India, South Africa and perhaps by Germany. I don’t think these countries actually condemn sanctions on Syria, but for domestic reasons that make their participation highly unlikely, these countries are more likely to decide to stay out of an armed conflict at the moment.
As it was decided, the responsibility to impose sanctions was passed on to the Arab League - and is going to remain there...
But if there is something that we all have to agree on, it is that there is strong evidence that foreign intervention in Syria could lead to the greatest war of the Arab history! 
What do you think?