Sunday, 13 January 2013

The unbelievable has happened to Venezuela



Following my last post on Venezuela, I think that we can now say that the unbelievable happened in that country. How foreseeable was it, though? Just one day before January 10th, the government announced that Chavez would not be able to make it on time. They decided that the inauguration should be postponed (indefinitely), and that Maduro should be the one in charge until then. Up until this part, taking into account Maduro’s previous declarations on TV, they did exactly as they said.

And on the other side, the opposition tried to go to the courts and change this situation. They defended that inauguration should be on the 10th, that a medical junta should be established, and that the Speaker of the National Assembly should be in charge of the country while no new president was elected. In Venezuela, though, Chavez is mostly considered a hero; and this move certainly was seen by many as if they were just trying to take advantage of Chavez’s current debility. By any means, the Venezuelan Supreme Court ended up recognizing the legality of what the government did. But, have they ever seen any unconstitutionality in Chavez, anyway?

But of course the opposition could imagine that, so they also wrote to the Secretary General of the OAS. They expected that the USA would interfere, or at least something would happen. Now, taking into account Insulza’s history, one could also imagine that he would not be willing to take a stand, or start a political war on this. He did what he had to do: basically, he said that if any country was not satisfied with the situation in Venezuela, it should bring the subject to the Permanent Council. He is a member of Chile’s Socialist Party, worked for Allende’s government, graduated in Law, is a former Chilean diplomat and Foreign Minister, and dedicated his life to studying about politics. He knows the value of his words, therefore he watches them very carefully.

But the unbelievable happened. No country took the situation anywhere – not even the USA wanted to comment the Venezuelan Supreme Court’s decision. And neither did Colombia, Mexico, or Chile. Maybe there has not been enough time to do so yet, but even if they did, what consequences would it have, anyway? Argentina would defend Chavez for several reasons, so would Bolivia, Ecuador, Nicaragua, Uruguay, and even Brazil.

In the US, this southern movement is called “the pink tide”, as a derogatory expression referring to the leftist leaders who are currently in power in South America. So as long as Venezuela remains peaceful and supplying oil at a reasonable price, it is like its traditional international opposition has given up on it.

The value of the national constitution was lost, and all that matters now is the popularity of a leader. In the meantime, Nicolás Maduro has the power, with no actual political role, and out of the constitutional mandate. He has not been elected for this role. The democratic processes have been forgotten, and a serious precedent was established. Again, Southern American diplomacy is proving its singularity.


Why bother, anyway?

Saturday, 5 January 2013

How much more unstable could the future of Venezuela be?



Cancer has been taking over south-American politics since the last years of the 00’s. The Paraguayan Fernando Lugo, started this dangerous trend with a lymphoma in 2010, and soon (Venezuela`s) Hugo Chavez came up with a similar problem, (Brazil’s former president) Lula, and finally (Argentina’s) Cristina Kirchner. Actually, even the current Brazilian president Rousseff was diagnosed with cancer in 2009, when she was still working for Lula as his Chief of Staff. If it is to be remembered, by the time she was starting to run for president in 2010, she was still wearing a wig for public appearances.

But speaking of Chavez, as he is the one in focus, he had his own opinion about this unfortunate new South-American political trend. According to him, even the USA could be culpable for the spread of the disease. In a declaration directed to his troops in 2011, he said: “It would not be strange if they had developed the technology to induce cancer and nobody knew about it until now ... I don't know. I'm just reflecting”. "But this is very, very, very strange ... it's a bit difficult to explain this, to reason it, including using the law of probabilities."

The fact is that a little more than a year after Chavez found out about his health condition, there he was, winning again the presidential elections in his country; earning himself the right to stay in power until 2019. Strangely, the 2012 elections were the hardest one for Chavez since he took office in 1999. The centrist Capriles, who had gained national significance as the governor of Miranda state, almost made it in the end, with 44.49% of the votes and the highest ever voter turnout. However, it is possible that the competition this time was too much for the fragile health of Chavez.  Right now it is known that the current and re-elected leader of Venezuela is laid on a bed of a hospital in the city of Habana, Cuba.

According to the information released to the public, he is between life and death, leaving the political future of his country much unknown. If he is unable to take the oath of office and be sworn in, technically he can’t be considered president, and new elections must be called. It must be said, though, that according to the constitution of that country, Chavez wouldn't necessarily have to be in Venezuela for his inauguration. As per art 231 of the Venezuelan Constitution, he could simply do it to the Supreme Court - from Cuba.

The problem is that he is too weak for anything. And as he is not responding properly to the treatments, he is clearly unable to be inaugurated. But all would be better if this judgement was this quick and easy. As per art 233 of the Constitution, the Supreme Court would need to designate (with the National Assembly`s approval) a special medical commission to deeply evaluate Chavez’s conditions. And given the support the president has in congress, it seems clear that nothing happen before due date.

Before December 2012, it would be hard for anyone to think of a successor for Chavez in Venezuela. After the announcement given by Chavez himself on the State sponsored channel (TeleSur), “if anything happened to him”, the person he would want to carry on his political project is his current vice-president Nicolás Maduro - a person who was a bus driver in his early life, and entered politics as an unofficial unionist back in 80’s. Out of curiosity, their close relationship dates back to 1994, when Maduro’s wife headed Chavez’s defense in the courts, releasing him from prison after his coup attempt in 1992. His wife, by the way, apart from being an ex-deputy of Venezuela, currently keeps the office of Attorney-General in that country. Maduro has been a congressman a few times, was a member of the Constituent Assembly in 1999, elected Speaker of the National Assembly in 2005, and then nominated Foreign Minister for Chavez in 2006.

NOTE: Considering the radical positions Venezuela has been taking in the international arena and Maduro's position in the government, this may indicate that he was the one behind much of what the world always disliked about Chavez. On the other hand, however, many analysts would say that Chavez has always been too much of a centralizer to follow the opinions of others... And from a honest point of view, this is what makes these days so uncertain for Venezuela. No one knows for sure what to expect from the next president. After all, differently from Lula, who, one could say, was just as strong in Brazil as Chavez is in Venezuela, he hadn’t got the time to prepare a successor for the job – nor the public for a different face.  

If in the end new elections are called, Capriles may come again to the scene. Last year he made a few mistakes in the presidential elections, which he is probably rethinking right now. If he wants to have a better chance in 2013, though, one of the main obstacles this time might be gathering the opposition again and moving a little further central. The parties did it last year, but at the moment they do not even know who to nominate in case of new elections.

If eventually the status quo is to be followed, Maduro will win with a huge advantage in the polls, and the interesting thing is that even the so–called Chavismo may suffer a few changes in the short/medium term. Considering that a new guy will be in office, and that the need for more inner respect will be clear, it is likely that politics in Venezuela turn even a little more authoritarian after Chavez. Just as a start, right now he is trying to frame up the opposition, warning the people about a mysterious coup attempt on TV. Also, in many occasions he is showing little respect for the constitution, e.g. by defending that the inauguration is a mere formality.

By any means, the commander’s premature absence from government can be a true window of opportunity for Venezuela’s new political theatre. Without Chavez, even though Maduro now counts with big enough support from his party and could be considered an already well-established politician in the country, the easy forecast is that he will not be nearly as strong and invincible as his predecessor. No one will be as charismatic as Chavez; no one to come will have the same attachments to the armed forces. By the way, one of the good things is that no one will have the same patience to star the endless appearances on national TV.

At the end, Venezuela can be living right now the beginning of a new era for its politics.